“Out of Many,” Only ONE Type is an Acceptable Representative

The other day I read an article by Kevin O’Brien Chang that put Jamaica’s choice of beauty queens to shame. He questioned why it was a practice for us to constantly choose a representative that never does fairly represent us all. I’ve been wondering this all my life. Now according to our motto, “Out of many, one people” you can’t really expect every representative to look all of Caucasian, African, Indian and Chinese at the same time, but there is something wrong when MOST of the time, the chosen ones only look like HALF that mix [which usually excludes the African and Chinese of us]. How many of our Miss Jamaica Worlds/Universes have had slits for eyes or really plump lips? How many have had short, kinky hair? If the winner’s personality outshines the others, fine. But over the years, am I to believe that not enough Chinese/darker-skinned contestants have the ‘right’ character? Only lighter-skinned, straight-nosed, uptown ones that have more of an American accent do?

Remember when that one rasta girl won Miss Jamaica Universe 2007 (Zahra Redwood), how shock ensued in both the upper and lower class realms? How everyone wondered what miracle made her win? Some happy about it (mainly the black some) and others not so much? How, after the happy some celebrated, they said under their breaths, “Well she nah go reach far pon di worl’ stage anyway cuz she nuh look like di res’ a dem”? 

To be honest, I think the Miss Jamaica World pageant has shown the world a better representative than the Miss Ja Universe pageant has. Comapre the two for yourself. Have a look at the most current 6 winners of Miss Jamaica World and Universe respectfully:

Sanneta Myrie MJW 2015
Sanneta Myrie MJW 2015
MJU 2015 Sharlene Radlein
MJU 2015 Sharlene Radlein
Laurie-Ann Chin MJW 2014
Laurie-Ann Chin MJW 2014
Kaci Fennell MJU 2014
Kaci Fennell MJU 2014
Gina Hargitay MJW 2013
Gina Hargitay MJW 2013
Kerrie Baylis MJU 2013
Kerrie Baylis MJU 2013
DEANNA Robins MJW 2012
DEANNA Robins MJW 2012
Chantal Zaky MJU 2012
Chantal Zaky MJU 2012
Danielle Crosskill MJW 2011
Danielle Crosskill MJW 2011
Shakira Martin MJU 2011
Shakira Martin MJU 2011
Chantal A. Raymond MJW 2010
Chantal A. Raymond MJW 2010
YENDI Phillips MJU 2010
YENDI Phillips MJU 2010

Do you see a trend?

To read Chang’s article, you can view it here.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s